Small waves arrive in groups.
A slower motion follows.
Watch a beach for several minutes and the shoreline may advance and retreat on a rhythm much slower than the individual incoming waves. Infragravity waves occupy this lower-frequency part of the surface motion. Understanding them starts with a distinction: the envelope of a short-wave group is not itself an extra wave in the elevation spectrum.
Grouping and a long wave are different.
Two nearby frequencies add to produce alternating groups of larger and smaller waves. Their linear sum still contains only those two frequencies. Its amplitude envelope varies slowly, but that envelope is a derived quantity, not a third sinusoid in the surface elevation.
A real low-frequency elevation component requires additional physics or an independently present long wave. Nonlinear interactions and spatial variations in the momentum carried by short waves can produce such a response. Calling every visible group an infragravity wave confuses the forcing pattern with the resulting water-level motion.
Bound and free describe different behaviour.
A bound long wave remains coupled to its forcing group. In the classical weakly nonlinear, uniform-depth picture, the slowly varying surface is depressed beneath the larger waves and elevated beneath the smaller waves. Its propagation is tied to the group, so treating it as an independent free wave with its own linear dispersion relation would be inappropriate.
A free long wave can propagate independently of the short-wave group. Changes in depth and breaking can alter the coupling and contribute to the generation or release of free infragravity waves. These processes do not reduce to simply switching off the short waves at one point.
Separate the envelope from the elevation.
This experiment uses an exact two-frequency short-wave signal and an optional prescribed slow elevation component. The slow component has the phase relationship of a bound-wave illustration. Its amplitude is chosen with a slider, not predicted from the short-wave amplitude, water depth or a nonlinear wave model.
Blue: ηshort. Dashed: ± envelope. The dotted line marks the selected instant.
Coral: ηslow, with a depression beneath the centre of a large group when enabled. This panel uses its own vertical scale.
Navy: ηshort + ηslow. All three panels share the same time axis.
Each stem has units m². Blue: the two short-wave components. Coral: the optional slow component. Stem width has no physical meaning.
Each short-wave component has amplitude a = 0.25 m. Their mean frequency is 0.125 Hz (8 s). The view spans two group periods and changes length with Δf. This is a time-series experiment, not a spatial beach simulation.
Three comparisons that reveal the mechanism.
- Select “Short waves only”. Large and small groups remain, but the elevation signal has no component at Δf. A slow envelope alone is not evidence of an infragravity elevation wave.
- Enable the prescribed component. Its variance appears at Δf, and the combined elevation shifts downward under large groups. No energy-transfer calculation has taken place: the experiment adds a specified signal.
- Halve Δf. The group period doubles. The periods of the individual short waves remain close to 8 s; there is no universal rule that the group period must be a fixed multiple of the short-wave period.
A 100-second rhythm from waves near eight seconds.
With f1 = 0.120 Hz and f2 = 0.130 Hz, individual periods are 8.333 s and 7.692 s. The repeating group envelope has period 1/(f2 − f1) = 100 s. Each 0.25 m amplitude component contributes 0.25²/2 = 0.03125 m² variance. The linear short-wave sum therefore contributes 0.06250 m².
If the separately prescribed slow amplitude is B = 0.06 m, its variance is 0.06²/2 = 0.00180 m². Total component variance is 0.06430 m². The component budget is exact for a common-period average; a short arbitrary observation window need not give exactly that sample variance.
What changes near a beach?
Infragravity motion can involve more than one generation mechanism. Short-wave groups can force bound low-frequency motion outside the breaking region. The breaking location and the distribution of breaking can also vary with the arriving groups, producing low-frequency forcing. Reflection at the shoreline and interactions with the bathymetry then modify the observed signal. Surf beat describes slow surf-zone fluctuations; it is not a single universally applicable formula.
Periods of tens to hundreds of seconds are useful introductory scales, but the boundary between infragravity and sea-swell bands depends on the application and the incident spectrum. State the frequency limits whenever reporting band-integrated variance or height. The experiment's 50–200 s slow periods are teaching choices, not a definition covering all environments.
Exact signal mathematics and the difference-frequency distinction
The signed modulation cos(πΔf t) has period 2/Δf, but its absolute amplitude envelope repeats after 1/Δf. This explains a common factor-of-two mistake. Squaring the short-wave signal creates a difference-frequency term through a product identity. A low-frequency peak in the squared signal or envelope therefore does not prove that the original elevation record contains that component.
The prescribed ηslow is anticorrelated with A²: A² = 2a²[1 + cos(2πΔf t)]. This establishes the displayed phase relationship only. It does not derive the amplitude of a physically generated bound wave. When the slow wave is disabled, its effective B is zero; the two short-wave components are unchanged.
For these selected frequencies, an 800 s record contains an integer number of every component's cycles. Independent verification uses that common duration to compare sample variance and Fourier-bin amplitudes with the analytical component values. The displayed two-group window serves visual interpretation and is not used to estimate the plotted stem variances.
Measurements, modelling and what the experiment leaves out
To observe slow motions, a record must be long enough to contain many of their cycles, with instrument response and processing suitable for the low-frequency band. Detrending and high-pass filtering can remove part of the desired signal. Tides, surge, instrument drift and nonstationarity must be distinguished from wave-band variability rather than absorbed into a generic “long wave”.
Separating bound and free motions usually requires information about propagation and coupling, such as spatial measurements and phase relationships. A single elevation spectrum cannot uniquely identify the generation mechanism. A phase-averaged model configured only for sea-swell frequencies does not automatically resolve infragravity wave generation or its phase relationships. Appropriate long-wave coupling or a suitable phase-resolving model requires separate verification.
This illustration does not solve radiation-stress forcing, nonlinear transfer, depth transformation, breaking, release, reflection, shoreline run-up or resonance. No wave-driven currents are calculated. Increasing B adds prescribed variance without reducing short-wave variance; it must not be interpreted as a conservative simulation of energy transfer. No site forecast or design value is supplied.