LEARN / OCEAN WAVES / CHAPTER 16

Choosing the Wave Theory

Full original scientific lesson and experiments, reorganized into a dedicated chapter.

Original physics and annotationsInteractive scientific demonstrationsScientific teaching examples

Scientific scope: This lesson retains the original scientific explanations, diagrams, equations and interactive demonstrations. All numerical examples are educational and subject to their stated assumptions; they are not independently field-validated engineering design tools or operational forecasts.

CHAPTER 16 / CHOOSING THE DESCRIPTION

Choose the theory
for the question.

A wave theory is a set of assumptions and equations. Its usefulness depends on the conditions and on what needs to be predicted: a steady profile, local pressure, an evolving wave train or the statistics of an irregular sea.

The previous chapter showed one correction to a sinusoid. Adding terms is not always the best next step. Long waves in shallow water require a different balance of nonlinearity and dispersion, while an evolving coastal wave field requires equations that can follow changes through space and time.

Different descriptions answer different questions
DescriptionUseful starting pointWhat to check
Linear / AirySmall-amplitude waves; dispersion, first-order kinematics and superposition.Small corrections for the quantity of interest. A good period prediction does not ensure accurate crest pressure.
Stokes expansionPeriodic finite-amplitude waves, especially outside strongly nonlinear shallow-water conditions.Order and convergence; successive corrections should decrease. Second order is a shape illustration, not a universal substitute for higher orders.
CnoidalPeriodic, long, nonlinear shallow-water waves; pronounced crests separated by long troughs.Shallow-water assumptions and the specific approximation order. Its elliptic-function profile is not a cosine with an arbitrary crest sharpened.
SolitaryAn isolated long elevation pulse in shallow water.No repeating wave period or finite periodic wavelength. A solitary pulse is a limiting idealization, not a whole irregular sea state.
Stream-function / Fourier solutionA numerical steady periodic wave satisfying nonlinear free-surface conditions over a flat bed.Resolution, convergence and residual boundary-condition errors. A converged steady solution does not model overturning or an evolving breaking wave.
Boussinesq-type equationsEvolution of long waves, including interactions and propagation over varying bathymetry.Dispersion and nonlinearity range of the chosen formulation. Breaking and dissipation require additional treatment; the family has no single universal validity range.

Locate a wave in parameter space.

The diagram plots relative depth d/L against relative height H/d on logarithmic axes. The point comes from H, T and d, using linear dispersion to estimate L for initial screening. The lines are contours of UR, not borders between certified theories.

Each equal step on a logarithmic axis multiplies the value. Coral dashed line: Miche limiting-steepness estimate expressed as H/d. A point below it is not automatically safe or accurately described.

Editable range: H 0.05–8 m, T 2–25 s, d 1–100 m. Invalid or empty inputs pause the diagram.

How the guide produces its advice

First it checks whether the proposed wave reaches the Miche estimate or H/d ≥ 0.8. These are warning screens, not a simulation of breaking. It then identifies long shallow waves using d/L < 1/8 and UR > 20 as a broad educational cue toward cnoidal or Boussinesq descriptions. CEM discusses a cnoidal range of this kind, but published criteria vary with formulation and error tolerance.

Otherwise, b/a ≤ 0.05 together with ka ≤ 0.05 and H/d ≤ 0.1 indicates a small shape correction in this guide. Remaining cases prompt investigation of higher-order Stokes or a converged numerical steady-wave solution. These rules explain the displayed advice; they do not replace a validated selection chart, a convergence study or a check of the output quantity that matters. A numerical wavelength may differ from this initial linear estimate.

Periodicity is a physical choice.

Stokes, cnoidal and numerical steady-wave solutions describe repeating waves. A solitary-wave solution instead approaches still water on either side of one pulse. A leading shallow-water expression is η = H sech²[√(3H/4d³)(x − ct)], with c ≈ √(gd)(1 + H/2d), where H/d must be small enough for the approximation. No arbitrary repeating period should be attached to this pulse.

Cnoidal waves form a periodic long-wave family. As crests become widely separated, their form approaches an isolated-pulse limit. This is a conceptual connection between theories, not permission to apply a solitary profile to every large coastal wave.

Steady profiles and evolving seas.

A stream-function or Fourier solution solves a nonlinear steady-wave problem. The Fourier coefficients are determined together with the free-surface conditions; this is different from taking an FFT of measured elevations.

Boussinesq-type models evolve the wave motion and retain phase information. Phase-averaged spectral models instead evolve a statistical distribution in frequency and direction. Neither description is simply a more detailed version of the other: they retain different information and suit different scales and questions.

A practical sequence for choosing.

  1. Define the desired quantity and allowable error: surface crest, velocity, pressure, transformation or sea-state statistics.
  2. Check the physical setting: periodic or irregular, steady or evolving, uniform or varying depth, nonbreaking or breaking.
  3. Estimate d/L, H/L, H/d and UR using a consistent convention. Treat them as screening information.
  4. Compare suitable formulations, verify numerical convergence and check against an independent solution or measurements where available.
  5. Keep input uncertainty separate from theory and discretization errors. More equations cannot recover missing information about the waves.