Choose the theory
for the question.
A wave theory is a set of assumptions and equations. Its usefulness depends on the conditions and on what needs to be predicted: a steady profile, local pressure, an evolving wave train or the statistics of an irregular sea.
The previous chapter showed one correction to a sinusoid. Adding terms is not always the best next step. Long waves in shallow water require a different balance of nonlinearity and dispersion, while an evolving coastal wave field requires equations that can follow changes through space and time.
| Description | Useful starting point | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Linear / Airy | Small-amplitude waves; dispersion, first-order kinematics and superposition. | Small corrections for the quantity of interest. A good period prediction does not ensure accurate crest pressure. |
| Stokes expansion | Periodic finite-amplitude waves, especially outside strongly nonlinear shallow-water conditions. | Order and convergence; successive corrections should decrease. Second order is a shape illustration, not a universal substitute for higher orders. |
| Cnoidal | Periodic, long, nonlinear shallow-water waves; pronounced crests separated by long troughs. | Shallow-water assumptions and the specific approximation order. Its elliptic-function profile is not a cosine with an arbitrary crest sharpened. |
| Solitary | An isolated long elevation pulse in shallow water. | No repeating wave period or finite periodic wavelength. A solitary pulse is a limiting idealization, not a whole irregular sea state. |
| Stream-function / Fourier solution | A numerical steady periodic wave satisfying nonlinear free-surface conditions over a flat bed. | Resolution, convergence and residual boundary-condition errors. A converged steady solution does not model overturning or an evolving breaking wave. |
| Boussinesq-type equations | Evolution of long waves, including interactions and propagation over varying bathymetry. | Dispersion and nonlinearity range of the chosen formulation. Breaking and dissipation require additional treatment; the family has no single universal validity range. |
Locate a wave in parameter space.
The diagram plots relative depth d/L against relative height H/d on logarithmic axes. The point comes from H, T and d, using linear dispersion to estimate L for initial screening. The lines are contours of UR, not borders between certified theories.
Each equal step on a logarithmic axis multiplies the value. Coral dashed line: Miche limiting-steepness estimate expressed as H/d. A point below it is not automatically safe or accurately described.
Editable range: H 0.05–8 m, T 2–25 s, d 1–100 m. Invalid or empty inputs pause the diagram.
How the guide produces its advice
First it checks whether the proposed wave reaches the Miche estimate or H/d ≥ 0.8. These are warning screens, not a simulation of breaking. It then identifies long shallow waves using d/L < 1/8 and UR > 20 as a broad educational cue toward cnoidal or Boussinesq descriptions. CEM discusses a cnoidal range of this kind, but published criteria vary with formulation and error tolerance.
Otherwise, b/a ≤ 0.05 together with ka ≤ 0.05 and H/d ≤ 0.1 indicates a small shape correction in this guide. Remaining cases prompt investigation of higher-order Stokes or a converged numerical steady-wave solution. These rules explain the displayed advice; they do not replace a validated selection chart, a convergence study or a check of the output quantity that matters. A numerical wavelength may differ from this initial linear estimate.
Periodicity is a physical choice.
Stokes, cnoidal and numerical steady-wave solutions describe repeating waves. A solitary-wave solution instead approaches still water on either side of one pulse. A leading shallow-water expression is η = H sech²[√(3H/4d³)(x − ct)], with c ≈ √(gd)(1 + H/2d), where H/d must be small enough for the approximation. No arbitrary repeating period should be attached to this pulse.
Cnoidal waves form a periodic long-wave family. As crests become widely separated, their form approaches an isolated-pulse limit. This is a conceptual connection between theories, not permission to apply a solitary profile to every large coastal wave.
Steady profiles and evolving seas.
A stream-function or Fourier solution solves a nonlinear steady-wave problem. The Fourier coefficients are determined together with the free-surface conditions; this is different from taking an FFT of measured elevations.
Boussinesq-type models evolve the wave motion and retain phase information. Phase-averaged spectral models instead evolve a statistical distribution in frequency and direction. Neither description is simply a more detailed version of the other: they retain different information and suit different scales and questions.
A practical sequence for choosing.
- Define the desired quantity and allowable error: surface crest, velocity, pressure, transformation or sea-state statistics.
- Check the physical setting: periodic or irregular, steady or evolving, uniform or varying depth, nonbreaking or breaking.
- Estimate d/L, H/L, H/d and UR using a consistent convention. Treat them as screening information.
- Compare suitable formulations, verify numerical convergence and check against an independent solution or measurements where available.
- Keep input uncertainty separate from theory and discretization errors. More equations cannot recover missing information about the waves.