When a crest grows sharper.
Linear theory describes a wave as a symmetric oscillation about the mean surface. Finite-amplitude waves can have higher, narrower crests and broader, shallower troughs. The change in shape matters even when the crest-to-trough height stays the same.
Small compared with what?
Wave height alone cannot tell whether linear theory is adequate. A one-metre wave can be relatively gentle in deep water yet occupy a substantial fraction of a shallow water column. The relevant comparisons are the height with wavelength, H/L, and with depth, H/d. Relative depth d/L identifies how strongly the bed influences the motion.
The steepness parameter ka = πH/L measures the slope scale of the leading sinusoid, where a = H/2. In shallow water, weak dispersion can make nonlinear effects important even when H/L is small. The Ursell number UR = HL²/d³ combines relative height and relative depth: UR = (H/d)/(d/L)². This lesson uses that definition throughout; other normalizations include different constant factors.
A harmonic that belongs to the wave.
A second-order Stokes profile adds a smaller oscillation at twice the fundamental frequency and wavenumber. Its phase is locked to the fundamental: it raises the crest and also raises the trough toward the mean surface. It is a bound harmonic, not a separately chosen free wave.
This distinction connects directly to the FFT lesson. A peak at twice the frequency may reflect nonlinear wave shape. It does not, by itself, prove that a separate wave system is present. Randomizing this harmonic's phase would destroy the particular Stokes shape.
Compare one wavelength.
Change H, T and d, then move the phase cursor. Both curves use the same wavelength from linear dispersion and the same H. This is a regular progressive wave over a horizontal bed, not a shoaling calculation.
Blue: linear profile. Coral: second-order profile. Vertical scale adjusts to H; the horizontal axis is x/L. This is not an equal-scale drawing.
Read the correction, not just the curve.
Write η = a cosψ + b cos2ψ, with ψ = kx − ωt. The ratio b/a measures the size of the second harmonic relative to the first. While the retained profile has its crest at ψ = 0 and trough at ψ = π, their elevations are a + b and −a + b. Their difference remains 2a = H. A higher crest therefore does not imply a larger crest-to-trough height in this comparison.
The second-order formula and its limits
ω = 2π/T, ω² = gk tanh(kd), L = 2π/k, a = H/2
σ = tanh(kd), b = ka²(3 − σ²)/(4σ³)
η(x,t) = a cos(kx − ωt) + b cos[2(kx − ωt)]
The equivalent coefficient is b = (πH²/8L) cosh(kd)[2 + cosh(2kd)]/sinh³(kd). In deep water σ tends to one and b tends to ka²/2. In shallow water the coefficient grows strongly, signalling the failure of this expansion if its correction is no longer small. Linear dispersion supplies k at this order; higher-order amplitude-dependent corrections to phase speed are not calculated here.
The display uses conservative teaching screens ka ≤ 0.2, H/d ≤ 0.3 and b/a ≤ 0.25, plus a Miche steepness screen. These are transparent interface choices, not validated error bounds. Passing them does not certify accuracy. The b/a = 0.25 boundary also marks the onset of additional stationary points in this two-harmonic profile: beyond it, an artificial secondary crest can develop in the trough.
The Miche comparison is H/L ≈ 0.142 tanh(kd), a limiting-steepness estimate, not a universal surf-zone breaking law. A case near that limit needs a different assessment even if a curve can be drawn. When any display screen fails, only the linear reference remains; it too must not be interpreted as a reliable prediction for that case.
Three experiments to try.
- Reduce H while holding T and d fixed. The first harmonic scales with H, but the second scales with H². The relative correction therefore shrinks.
- Return to H = 2 m and T = 8 s, then reduce d. Watch the Ursell number and b/a increase. A small H/L alone does not guarantee a useful Stokes expansion.
- Move the phase cursor. The two harmonics translate together; their relative phase stays fixed. The shape changes position, not form.
Height skewness versus wave-front asymmetry: not the same quantity
A sharply peaked crest with a broad trough has nonzero vertical (crest–trough) skewness. A wave leaning or pitching to one side has front–back asymmetry. The two need not increase together. We can illustrate the difference with a controlled two-harmonic signal, η(φ) = A cos φ + B cos(2φ + δ), where A and B (m) are harmonic amplitudes, φ is phase (rad) increasing in time at a fixed station, and δ is harmonic phase offset (rad).
Blue: prescribed elevation η; dashed grey: first harmonic A cos φ. Coral dotted curve: temporal phase slope dη/dφ, shown on its own normalized scale (not metres). Axes and legends identify both quantities.
The displayed elevation skewness is the standardized central third moment, Sk(η) = ⟨η³⟩/⟨η²⟩3/2 (zero-mean signal). For this two-harmonic example: ⟨η²⟩ = (A² + B²)/2 and ⟨η³⟩ = (3A²B/4) cos δ. To expose phase asymmetry, the second readout uses a clearly defined temporal phase-slope skewness, Sk(η′) = ⟨(dη/dφ)³⟩/⟨(dη/dφ)²⟩3/2. This is a teaching diagnostic, not the standardized Hilbert-transform asymmetry coefficient used in some field studies. Its sign depends on whether phase is oriented forward in time or space.
Interpretation: δ = 0 gives a narrow high crest but zero phase-slope skewness; δ = 90° gives zero elevation skewness but nonzero phase-slope skewness. This arbitrary harmonic superposition is not a hydrodynamically solved Stokes or Boussinesq wave for every δ. The amplitude ratio is restricted for diagram clarity, not by a universal physical validity threshold. Crest-to-trough height is recalculated as δ changes; it is not assumed to remain 2A.
Source and terminology: Bosboom & Stive, Coastal Dynamics (2023), §5.3 (open-text rendering); Holthuijsen (2007), §5.6 for the limitations of finite-amplitude approximations. Equations and diagrams here are independently formulated for teaching.