When a wave
becomes surf.
The earlier experiments stop at a boundary. Here we examine what that boundary means, why its position is uncertain, and what changes when an organised wave begins to break.
What changes at breaking?
A regular crest can no longer maintain its organised shape. Air is entrained, turbulence develops and wave energy is dissipated. Breaking also changes wave momentum flux, helping drive mean water-level changes and nearshore currents.
Before this point, real waves can already have narrow high crests, broad troughs and a steep front face. The sine waves in our earlier labs do not reproduce that nonlinear deformation.
Try this.
- Keep T = 8 s and γ = 0.78. Increase the input height and watch the estimated break move into deeper water.
- Restore H = 1 m. Compare γ = 0.60 and 0.90. A smaller assumed limit usually gives an earlier crossing in deeper water.
- Change the slope. In this simplified calculation, the breaking depth stays the same but its distance from the shoreline changes.
Real beach slope affects breaking behaviour too. Here it only converts depth into distance on a plane bed. That deliberate simplification makes the sensitivity experiment easy to interpret.
The two screening limits
The first term limits height relative to depth. The second is an approximate steepness limit associated with Miche. The lab searches from 50 m towards shore for the first intersection with the lossless, normal-incidence shoaling prediction.
This combination is a teaching rule. γ is not a universal constant, and combining two approximate limits does not create an exact breaking model.
Why we stop the height calculation here
Continuing the same lossless formula would send height towards unrealistically large values as depth approaches zero. In the surf zone, dissipation, nonlinear waves, rollers and mean flows become important. A separate model is needed to predict their evolution.
For irregular waves, different waves break at different locations; the surf-zone boundary is not a single permanent line. A criterion for individual regular-wave height should not be applied uncritically to significant wave height.
Scientific basis and model scope
Sorensen (2006), Basic Coastal Engineering, §2.8, printed pp. 38–41, discusses asymmetry, Miche’s approximate limit and breaker types. Reeve, Chadwick & Fleming (2018), Coastal Engineering, §2.6.2, printed pp. 61–65, discusses breaking, variable breaker indices and surf similarity. Holthuijsen (2007), §8.4.5, distinguishes depth-induced breaking parameterisations for irregular seas.
The predicted onset is approximate, based on linear shoaling with no currents, refraction, reflection or pre-breaking losses. The illustrated breaker shapes below are original qualitative drawings, not outputs of that model.
Three familiar ways a crest breaks.
Wave steepness and beach slope influence the behaviour. These are useful categories with gradual transitions, not three sharply separated states.
Spilling
Foam develops near the crest and spreads down the front as the wave advances. Often associated with gentler beaches and relatively steep incident waves.
Plunging
The crest curls over and falls onto the water ahead, often enclosing air. Energy release is more concentrated than in a spilling breaker.
Surging
Water surges up a steep boundary with limited development of an overturning crest. Reflection can be substantial. Collapsing breakers occupy part of the transition towards this behaviour.
Schematic snapshots only. The coral marks highlight the feature to notice; they are not a numerical foam or velocity field. No breaker type is assigned by the onset calculator.